Interviewed by Cherie
As Holly Kearl celebrates the upcoming release in August of her first book, “Stop Street Harassment: Making Public Places Safe and Welcoming for Women”, the activist and legal advocacy fund program manager for the AAUW (formerly known as the American Association of University Women) discusses the findings of the formal and informal research she did for her book and shares with us her thoughts on why street harassment is still a widespread but ignored or trivialized problem that the mainstream media rarely addresses as a serious issue. Holly also explains the connection between street harassment and the perception of women as sexual objects which is why she believes that “educating young men about healthy definitions of masculinity is number one.“ As she continues to create awareness of the problem through her blog Stop Street Harassment, Holly looks forward to a day when street harassment laws are in place and women can walk down the streets without fear of being harassed or assaulted just because they are female.
You have worked in various positions at the Natural Women’s Museum and at the AAUW before writing your master’s thesis on street harassment. What made you decide to make the transition into activism and writing about street harassment?
I started working at AAUW two weeks before I turned in my master’s thesis and, now, three years later, I still work there full-time. I wrote my street harassment book and run the blog and website in my spare time. At AAUW some of the programs I work on address sexual harassment at work and school as well as sexual assault on campus, so my street harassment efforts are related, and my coworkers are supportive of my street harassment work.
Your book, “Stop Street Harassment: Making Public Places Safe and Welcoming for Women” will be released in August, can you explain how you conducted your research on the subject?
In the first six chapters of the book, I examine various aspects of street harassment. To write them, I researched every existing study on street harassment that I could find. I also conducted an informal, online survey about people’s experiences with strangers in public and specifically with street harassers of the opposite sex. I conducted it across four weeks in the fall of 2008 and about 1300 people took it. Once I weeded out people who only answered questions like their age and race and not any of the substantial questions, I was left with 916 respondents, 811 were women. In my first six chapters then, I pulled from the formal and my informal studies to create my points and then used news stories, responses to the short answers in my survey, and stories submitted to my Stop Street Harassment Blog to illustrate my points.
In the last four chapters of the book, I look at how we can end street harassment. I interviewed more than 20 activists around the world and researched a dozen others’ experiences and advice to write these chapters.
What was the most surprising fact that you found out in the course of writing your book?
Many facts and stories I came across surprised me. For example, I was horrified and surprised by how pervasive groping is on the trains in Tokyo. I was also startled and dismayed when I realized that of the 811 women I informally surveyed, 75 percent had been followed and 57 percent had been touched or grabbed in a sexual way by a stranger in public. It makes me so mad when people dismiss street harassment as complimentary behavior or not that big of a deal because it is, if for no other reason than because so many of us have had men grope and follow us.
Do you think this issue has been addressed adequately in the media and if not then why?
Absolutely not. I am tired of seeing street harassment – when it is covered by mainstream media – so often framed as a debate, such as asking, is catcalling creepy or complimentary? Such discussions reduce the range of street harassment to only whistling and positive sexual comments, which some women do find complimentary in some circumstances. The news articles do not touch on the reality of how many women and girls are followed, touched, assaulted, and have negative and threatening comments made to them. They do not put the harassment into the context of rape culture, gender inequality, patriarchy, the sexualization of girls and women in the media, and victim blaming, which are all factors impacting why street harassment happens and why women don’t like it. The news articles too often make it seem like women just can’t take a compliment.
You have said that gender equity cannot happen until men stop harassing women in public spaces, what are some strategies that will help achieve this?
Educating young men about healthy definitions of masculinity is number one. Right now, masculinity means aggressive, powerful, violent, and getting with a lot of women and treating them like objects. Masculinity also means demonizing feminine characteristics, whether they’re exhibited by men or women; this contributes directly to gay bashing, gender patrolling among boys and men and harassing girls and women. Men Can Stop Rape has programs at U.S. high schools and colleges that focus on healthy definitions of masculinity and the International Center for Research on Women’s program Parivartan works on it in India. We need more groups like them.
Focusing on making men part of the solution is another strategy. Men listen to other men, so if men who don’t harass can try to be a good example to others, call out their friends who harass, and help a woman out (if she wants it) when she’s being harassed, those are useful roles for them in helping to end street harassment. The University of New Hampshire has a wonderful bystander campaign for men and women called “Know Your Power” and Jackson Katz, a leading anti-sexist male activist, has a great bystander-training program for men as part of his Mentors in Violence Prevention.
Culturally, we need street harassment taken seriously and not portrayed as a compliment. I can understand how it would be confusing to a young man to know how to treat young women when so many schools give no sex education and in music videos and in porn and on TV they see men harassing women and most women enjoying it or at least tolerating it. I love the new government-sponsored television ad campaigns in Wales and Scotland called “One Step Too Far” and “Not Ever,” which were targeted at men by being aired during the World Cup. They focus on showing why women don’t like to be harassed and how a woman’s clothes do not ever mean she’s “asking” to be raped. I’d love to see similar campaigns in the US during our football games. It would be so powerful if an ad about respect aired during the Super Bowl instead of the numerous commercials that are so disrespectful to women and men and reduce women to body parts and mock men who aren’t “macho” enough.
Are you ever worried that when women who talk back to or take a photo of their harasser may find themselves in an unsafe situation?
I always worry about women’s safety in street harassment situations. I’ve read news stories where women ignored a harasser or just said, “No,” or “I’m not interested” and the men turned around and stabbed them or shot them or threw garbage at them. Women can ignore them and men may escalate. Women can say, “Stop harassing me” and men may escalate. Women can curse and flip out and the men may escalate.
At the end of the day, we never know how our harasser will respond and that’s why it’s essential to get men who harass to stop. In the meantime, women do have to respond someway, so I advise them to quickly assess their feelings of safety and then do whatever feels the most empowering. Usually ignoring the harasser and doing nothing is not empowering and women wish they had done something or at least taken the harasser’s photo. So when they feel safe, I think they might as well respond that way. It’s always a gamble as far as how the harasser will respond so, being empowered and safe is all we can try to do as women.
A video game titled “Hey Baby” that just came out on the market allows you to gun down harassers who say all sorts of creepy and threatening things. Would you say that this game represents a positive contribution to the fight against street harassment?
Yes, I think it has had a positive contribution because it has received lots of attention in the news, including on NPR and in the New York Times, and generated discussions about street harassment. Street harassment is so rarely acknowledged as a problem in the news and this game prompted many journalists and bloggers to acknowledge that it is one, and not in the “women can’t take a compliment” way. I was pleased by the New York Times review of the game, particularly at the end of the article when the male author said that playing the game made him understand women’s experiences more and that, while he’s never street harassed a woman, after playing the game, he never will.
How does one respond to men who claim that women who dress provocatively are asking for attention?
The way a woman is dressed does not tell him if she wants to be commented on. If she looks dressed up, do not assume it is to gain the admiration of all men she sees and that he should say something to her. She may enjoy dressing up, she may be dressed up for an event, or she may be dressed up to gain the admiration of a specific person or persons. Everyone should always treat women – and men – with respect, no matter what they are wearing.
Also, no matter what women wear, there are men who will harass them. It is not about what we wear, but about the fact that we are women in public, usually alone. Further, men in countries like Egypt and Yemen still harass women even though they are very modestly dressed and sometimes even completely veiled. In Egypt, a study showed 83 percent of women had been harassed and in Yemen, it was 90 percent. I’ve read articles where men justify their behavior by saying the women shouldn’t be out in public alone or by saying they think the women must have something to hide and must be very beautiful if they’re covered.
Do you think it is important to consider men’s stories of street harassment as well?
At this point I have not asked for men’s street harassment stories for my blog unless they were bystanders or with women being harassed. Men are more often harassed for their race, class, sexual orientation, disability, disability, or nationality, and usually by other men, and I think that people generally understand that to be wrong behavior. Women are also harassed for those reasons, but I found in my survey that they are harassed most often because of their gender. And because right now most people don’t realize that or care and dismiss such behavior as complimentary, flirting, and harmless, I am focused on (more…)